Monday 9 A.M. You are ready to go with all your equipment and all you need is your cup of coffee which is your favorite. Marketing metrics on the dashboard on your screen are flashing open rates, click-through rates, and the conversions. But something feels off. Your last email campaign did not go so well and for some reason you are unable to understand why this is the case.
Take some time before you go into the numbers or summon everyone to an emergency team meeting. There must be a possibility that there is something that was not solved during the time when you were making calculations. It may sound strange to discuss something as trivial as email regulations?
This leads us to the year 2024, where the strategies of email marketing continue to emerge and remain on guard to avoid the pitfalls of falling foul of the regulation whilst also being good for business proposition in the world of B2B. So now, let’s take a closer look at the basic requirements under the email regulations that B2B software marketers and sales managers must be aware of this year and why they are especially relevant now.
Discover the secrets to crafting emails that get responses! Watch our video "5 Tips for an Effective Email Outreach Campaign" and elevate your email outreach efficiency today.
- The CAN-SPAM Act: The Backbone of U.S. Email Marketing
Picture this: A good email – or so you’ve composed one that you think is just perfect. The subject line is excellent, the content delivered is well taken, and your call to action is tempting. You press the send button but the email reaches the spam rather than making the magic to convert. What went wrong?
The CAN-SPAM Act lays down the rules applying to commercial emails in the United States, also known as ‘‘Controlling the Assault of Non-Solicited Pornography And Marketing” became effective in 2003 and its relevance has only increased in the year 2024. Currently, the FTC has scaled up on enforcement measures and any oversights which may be contained in the emails can cost your company highly, with $ 46,517 for each violation.
So, what exactly does CAN-SPAM require? At its core, the law mandates transparency and honesty in your email communications. This means every email must include the following:
- A clear and accurate subject line that isn’t misleading.
- A visible opt-out mechanism that allows recipients to unsubscribe easily.
- A valid physical postal address of your business.
- Proper identification that your message is an advertisement if it is one.
For example, let’s design an email message. How would you feel if the subject line captured you with a solution to your problem while the content provided you with another thing all together? So you must have thought that you could feel like this, right? Well, that is the very point CAN-SPAM wanted to address.
Your takeaway: It is not about finances and sanctions, it is about maintain people’s trust. It may be considered obvious but in a crowded inbox, trust cannot be overrated as the most important currency. Check to make sure that every email your team sends out is compliant with CAN-SPAM, and on top of that, build a powerful audience who is waiting to hear from you.
- GDPR: The Global Standard for Data Privacy
Why don’t we go back in time to May 2018 when the world witnessed the introduction of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)? Marketers all over the world were frantically putting together new privacy policies, inserting consent boxes and firing off re- permission letters. Jumping to 2024, GDPR remains an essential force in global email marketing, though especially affecting businesses targeting European customers.
Discover the difference between Open Rate and Click-Through Rate (CTR) and learn how to optimize your email marketing strategy. Read the full blog now to master these metrics and boost your campaign performance!
The GDPR is not simply a further regulation in this direction: it is a complete cultural change in the management of personal data. In short, it is aimed at putting the power back in the hands of the consumer and for marketing stakeholders, this translates into ask for prior and express consent before a marketing email is sent. Such a policy especially in the more modern world of today should do away with issues like pre-ticked consent boxes or basing consent based on previous communications.
Consider this scenario: You are currently ‘marketing’ to clientele in Europe that could potential do business with your company. You have gathered the e-mail addresses from Web-forms, trade shows, and of course, Linked In. But before you hit send, ask yourself: Is there an evidence that the senders of the emails have in one way or the other positively opted into receiving your mails? Otherwise, there is a look at the fines which may be in the range of Euro 20 million or 4 percent of the worldwide annual turnover whichever is more.
GDPR cannot be deemed as some sort of a tick-list to get through; it is all about respect. This is all about dignity that allows the audience to feel valued and maintained dependency on their persons’ information.
Your action plan: Regularly audit your email list to ensure you have proper consent for every contact. If you’re unsure, it’s better to ask for re-permission than to risk non-compliance. Also, ensure that your privacy policy is clear, concise, and easily accessible so your recipients know exactly how their data is used.
- CASL: Canada’s Strict Approach to Spam
Let’s take a trip north to Canada, where email marketing is governed by one of the strictest anti-spam laws in the world: that may include the Canadian Anti Spam Legislation (CASL).
Suppose you’re going into a new territory in Canada with B2B software solutions as your niche. You’ve got a list of potential leads, but before you hit send, there’s one crucial question you need to ask: Fields like explicit consent, implicit consent and implied consent as well as the common law doctrine of lose maius may come in handy.
Compared to CAN-SPAM that allows one to email someone as long as the recipient does not click on the ‘unsubscribe’ button, CASL expects you to seek permission, either express or implied to make that first email delivery.
CASL defines consent in two ways:
- Express Consent: This form of prominence or this type of advertising can be regarded as having the highest level of advertising, what people often refer to as the ‘gold standard’. It is when the recipients permit themselves to receive your emails by a tick of a box or complete an order form.
- Implied Consent: This can happen mostly in certain conditions, such as, there being a business relationship. But implied consent has a lifespan of approximately two years and at the end of this period, you can either cease such messages or seek for direct consent.
Now suppose you are in a trade show; someone drops their business card into your bowl. This act under CASL alone does not mean that you will keep on sending them marketing emails forever. You might have had obvious implied consent for sometime; however,if you want to keep that contact on your list, you’ll need the express consent.
Your best move: Assist in the process of subscription especially to those originating from Canada by adopting the double opt-in subscription process comprehensively throughout the organization. This also helps to guarantee that, to the maximum extent possible, the contacts are people who are interested in being in contact with you, and effectively help you ward off any CASL complaints.
- CCPA: The California Consumer Privacy Act
Now it’s time to turn back to the USA and, particularly, to California, where the legislation can also affect your email marketing efforts. The CCPA acts like a sister to the GDPR but has its peculiarities.
The CCPA provides Californian residents with additional rights for their personal data such as the right to know, delete and the right to opt-out. Although there is nothing specific about CCPA regarding email marketing, it has a bearing onhow you address the information behind the email marketing campaigns.
For example, if you are collecting data from users in California state, then collecting and using their data, then you must effectively communicate this to the users. Now if a person decides not to be associated with data collection in any way, you cannot force them, you have to accept their decision, period.
Consider this: You are a business that just released a new B2B software product, and starting building an email list from a landing page. According to CCPA, to obtain and process data you have to explain to visitors the purpose and how their data will be used, and also how they can stop their data from being used if they want to. Failing to meet these provisions could raise questions from the readers and bring about penalties, and lawsuits.
Your best bet: It is very important to make transparency the foundation from which you approach the issues of data collection. Security policies should be updated, stated clearly and placed for easy access by everyone. And always un-subscribe customers from the mailing list or stop collecting their data as soon as they request you to do so.
- UCPA and Emerging State Laws: The Next Frontier
Lastly, let’s discuss new entrants to the gospel of the techno-optimists. But if GDPR, CASL, and CCPA are not enough, here comes a hatful of states’ privacy laws in the U. S. starting from the beginning of 2024 including UCPA which stands for Utah Consumer Privacy Act.
The UCPA which came into force in 2024 is Utah’s solution to the increasing need for data protection. CCPA is quite similar but there are specificities that come with it, for instance data processing agreements. And Utah is not the only state doing it – Virginia and Colorado have already implemented their privacy laws and form a quilt of restrictions which B2B marketers have to work around.
Picture that you are a B2B marketer targeting the entire country’s population. The laws of individual states could therefore vary in terms of what needs to be disclosed, how opt out mechanisms should be implemented or how data should be handled. It reminds me of the game of trial whack-a- mole; one fine day you cover up a trial or rule it only for another to emerge the next day.
Your strategy:
- Compliance should not be a fire fighting process, one has to be proactive in dealing with the situation.
- Keep an eye on other state laws that may come up and adapt your email correspondences based on such laws.
- It is also possible that particular aspects of such work are best done by professionals — legal advisors or compliance officers.
- As you have seen, lack of information is a disadvantage rather than being happy in the state of ignorance in the provision of email marketing services.
Why Compliance is Your Competitive Advantage
At this stage, you may be overwhelmed by many things. Given the multitude of regulations one can easily think of compliance as a nuisance. But here’s the silver lining: That means that while compliance is fundamentally avoiding fines, more was being done to create trust, improve brand image, and ultimately get better performance.
The modern customers are privacy-conscious than ever before and any brand that takes time to ensure that its clients’ data is safe is one step ahead. When your audience is aware that you only have their best interest at heart, you will be able to get them to open your mails, share and even become brand ambassadors for your business.
Solving Common FAQs About Email Regulations
Navigating email regulations can seem daunting, but understanding the basics can resolve many common concerns. Here are answers to frequently asked questions to help you stay compliant while optimizing your email campaigns:
1. Can I send marketing emails to anyone on my list without prior consent?
No. Regulations like GDPR and CASL require explicit or implied consent before sending marketing emails. For instance, in Europe under GDPR, you must have evidence of opt-in consent. In Canada, even implied consent (e.g., through a prior business relationship) has time limitations and needs to be refreshed.
2. Do I need to include an unsubscribe option in all emails?
Yes. According to CAN-SPAM, GDPR, and CASL, every marketing email must have a clear and easily accessible option for recipients to unsubscribe. Failure to do so can result in hefty penalties.
3. How do I ensure my emails don’t violate privacy laws when targeting multiple regions?
Understand and comply with regional regulations such as GDPR for Europe, CASL for Canada, and CCPA for California. Always obtain consent, provide transparent data usage policies, and respect users' rights to opt out or request data deletion.
4. What happens if I violate email regulations?
Non-compliance can lead to significant financial penalties, ranging from thousands of dollars under CAN-SPAM to millions under GDPR. It can also damage your brand reputation and erode customer trust.
5. Are B2B marketers subject to these regulations?
Yes. While some regulations, like GDPR, have nuances for B2B communications, consent and transparency remain essential. Ensure your email campaigns follow the same compliance standards for B2B as for B2C.
6. How can I verify compliance with these regulations?
Conduct regular audits of your email lists, ensure you have documented consent, and use tools that help you manage compliance (e.g., double opt-in processes). Collaborate with legal advisors if you're uncertain about specific rules.
